The Mystery of HD Radio Dropouts: When Digital Isn’t Always Better
In the world of broadcast engineering, few technical challenges are as frustrating as intermittent audio problems. Recently, we encountered a particularly perplexing issue with our HD Radio transmission that left us scratching our heads for weeks. Our HD1 audio signal would randomly drop out for brief periods—anywhere from 0.3 seconds to 3 seconds—while the HD2 signal continued operating flawlessly. This contradiction immediately caught our attention because conventional wisdom suggests that if there’s an issue with the transport stream or the exciter, all HD channels should be affected. But that wasn’t happening in our case, making this technical mystery even more intriguing.
The troubleshooting process led us down numerous paths, each more confusing than the last. We meticulously checked every piece of equipment in our air chain: the Nautel NV30 transmitter, the HD multicast, the Omnia 9 processor—all were functioning perfectly with no errors or faults in the logs. Everything was up to date, yet the problem persisted. What made this even more baffling was that different monitoring equipment showed different results. The Inovonics 632 HD receiver consistently displayed the dropouts, while the newer Inovonics 551 mod monitor showed no issues whatsoever. This divergence in behavior between monitoring equipment added another layer of complexity to our investigation and suggested the problem might not be with our transmission chain at all.
After extensive investigation and consultation with colleagues at partner organizations, we uncovered something quite revealing: the issue appeared to be with the Inovonics 632 receivers themselves. Apparently, these units had a known flaw that the manufacturer had never publicly acknowledged. The newer 551 mod monitors handled the HD Radio data more effectively, masking the issue. Additionally, we learned that HD2 channels typically have a much larger buffer (around 40 seconds) in MP1 mode compared to HD1, giving them more “wiggle room” to recover from minor data issues. This explanation finally made sense of the puzzling symptom pattern we had been observing. This experience highlights a broader issue with HD Radio technology in the United States—it’s built on proprietary systems that lock broadcasters into specific manufacturers, making troubleshooting unnecessarily difficult and limiting innovation in the field. Countries that have adopted open digital radio standards have seen more competitive markets, more affordable equipment, and in some cases like Norway, have successfully transitioned to fully digital radio broadcasting. Until the US embraces a more open approach, broadcast engineers will continue facing these frustrating proprietary challenges that make what should be straightforward technical issues into complex mysteries.
Discover more from Fully Modulated
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
